‘they totally ripped it off from x, y and z’
This might contain some ranting, you've been warned
So, unless you've been living under a rock, or in a cave, or, you know, just avoiding civilisation in general, then, first, welcome back, I don't envy your temporary lack of internets connection.
But, second, and just as important, you might have heard of dA Muro, or you're playing with it now, or some such.
@dxd has already written an excellent journal/news article (give luff plx), on dA Muro and its numerous advantages and its great potential, as well as addressing some of its nay-sayers.
I just want to weigh in on the subject, in the only way I know how, a long winded rant replete with a plethora of verbosity (inside joke
).
One of the biggest complaints with regards to dA Muro is 'it's like, totally a rip off of x, y and/or z', and 'dA is stealing other peoples ideas' and 'it's supposed to be, like revolutionary and original, but I've seen it all before on website x'.
And so on, ad infinitum (or nauseum, depending on your constitution).
I'll let you all into a little secret (even if it is rather cliche, by now), there's no such thing as originality.
Well, there is, but 'originality' (as in, something that's truly original) is an extremely rare event to behold, and I'd go so far as to say that very few people genuinely get to actually experience it.
You want to complain about a lack of originality. Okay, fine, so, why aren't you complaining about the old masters. I mean, they clearly stole the idea of applying pigment to paper to make images from painters before their time, and they clearly stole the idea from previous generations. And so on until we reach the first hominids who had the bright spark of putting pigments on rocks that we now gawk at.
Originality, as we know it today, is not originality, but, the reformulation of memes (or ideas), into something new, and perhaps unexpected.
Introducing bona-fide 'digital art', as an alternative to traditional art, and providing new tools that suit the medium. It's not an original idea, it's just an extension of an old idea. The reapplication of a pre-existing meme to suite the tools and the times. Nothing new about it, just the application.
Back to dA Muro, with that little aside.
Are there other online drawing applications? Of course there are, and dA has never tried to hide that fact. Hell, some of these applications have features that dA Muro presently doesn't (like use in an instant messaging/chat room environment). But, does that mean that dA is 'stealing' ideas because other people have attempted this before, even with the same technologies?
No.
We are human (one presumes), we are rather predictable creatures. Those of us who use dA are all exposed to a similar culture, and we bring to that culture our own 'real' cultures. We all share memes (or ideas), we share common themes. We watch, largely, the same films, read the same books, listen to the same music, get exposed to the same sorts of concepts, and so on.
Is it any wonder why two people, born on opposite sides of the globe, can think of, say, a character that can fly, and has super speed and strength?
It shouldn't be.
We all share a similar meme set, it's part of being human. We share a common pool of concepts and knowledge (which is becoming even more generalised, thanks to the internets), so, two different people, from radically different cultural backgrounds, can independently think of two near identical concepts, all the way down to the execution of the thing.
Now, I'm not saying that dA was unaware of the various plugin based browser drawing apps, that'd be silly to suggest. But that doesn't mean that dA stole the idea, because if it did, why aren't you levelling that same criticism towards the various clones of these flash based drawing apps? And, why aren't you accusing all of them of trying to copy photoshop, or its ilk?
Also, just because you've seen something similar to dA Muro on another site, doesn't mean that the concept isn't somehow 'innovative' on this site.
This site has never had a built in means of being able to create art, being able to communicate in images, without the need to labouriously upload each new image, and so on. Now it does. And it's already starting to cascade into something that will probably be seen as a paradigm shift in dA ten years from now.
To be as basic as I can functionally be, just because something isn't original, does not mean it can't be innovative (two double negatives in as many paragraphs, I fail).
dA did something 'new', it took a known idea, and reformulated it in a new and exciting way.
It's getting people involved, it's getting people talking. Hell, it's even getting schlubs (remarkably apt self description, if I say so myself) like me, to actually get a tablet, or dust of their old one (in my case), and actually seriously consider using dA Muro for 'srs bsns'.
It's even got some writers (well, a writer, I think), interested in using it.
So, you've got Photoshop, or you've used 'insert flash/shockwave/java based drawing app here'. So what.
They're not dA Muro, and dA Muro is not them.
If you want to make 'real art', go ahead and use the application of your preference. You're not being forced to use dA Muro. However, dA Muro gives an opportunity to those who don't want to, or can't download an app or plugin to make 'real art'.
Either way, I'm personally more excited about the potential communications shift that dA Muro will bring, and I hope it will inspire many more ideas into the future.









